New results vindicate suspect 63-year-old claim on synthesis of first catenane

Catenane

Source: © Mikkel Juul Jensen/Science Photo Library

Researchers hoping to debunk Edel Wasserman’s doubted claims of the first interlinked rings end up supporting them

Over six decades after Edel Wasserman from Bell Telephone Laboratories claimed to have made the first mechanically interlocked hydrocarbon rings – without direct evidence – UK chemists have supported his findings.1  For six years David Leigh’s team at the University of Manchester sought to show that Wasserman’s 1960 letter to the Journal of the American Chemical Society  was wrong. 2  In it, the US chemist claimed the first interlocked pair of rings, which he called a catenane.  But after Leigh’s group painstakingly reproduced Wasserman’s work, ‘it must have been formed in his reaction’, he concludes.